EUDOXUS (408-355 BC): THE VOLUME OF A CYLINDER, CONE, PRISM and PYRAMID

About 2000 years ago Eudoxus calculated the Volume of a Cylinder, an inscribed Cone, a Prism, and an inscribed Pyramid to be:

Volume = (Area*)(h)Volume = 1/3 (Area)(h)

Volume = (Area)(h)Volume = 1/3(Area)(h)


* where Area is the Area of the Base and h equals the height.

In modern parlance, how did he arrive at these calculations? Why is the volume of the inscribed figure, Cone or Pyramid, 1/3 the Volume of its "parent" figure, Cylinder or Prism?

If the Prism is a Rectangular Prism in which a Rectangular Pyramid is inscribed, Eudoxus partitioned, for example, the inscribed Rectangular Pyramid with "n" small Rectangles having "x" width and height "h". The total area of the partitioned-inscribed Rectangular Pyramid is the sum of all the areas of its composit Rectangles. Since the measure of Area is expressed in "squared units", i.e., 1 cm X 1 cm = 1 cm 2, the Volume of the inscribed rectangular Pyramid is the Sum of all the "squared composit smaller Areas:

  • Volume = (Sum of all areas of the smaller Rectangles)(h). The Sum of Squares is equal to:
    • (n(n +1)(2n +1))/6; for volumetric calculations: (n(n +1)(2n +1))/(6n3)

  • Volume = (n(n +1)(2n +1))/(6n3)(Area)(h) = (2n3 + 3n2 + n)/(6n3)(Area)(h) = (1/3 + 1/2n + 1))/(6n2)(Area)(h): as "n" becomes very large, 1/2n + 1/6n2 = 0, so that:

  • Volume = 1/3(Area of the Base)(h)

GENERALLY:

  1. For a Cylinder: Volume = (r2)(h)
    • For a Cone: Volume = 1/3(r2)(h)

  2. For Rectangular Prism: Volume = (l)(w)(h)
    • For a inscribed Rectangular Pyramid: Volume = 1/3((l)(w)(h))

  3. For a Triangular Prism: Volume = 1/2(altitude)(base)(h)
    • For and inscribed Triangular Pyramid: Volume = 1/3( 1/2(altitude)(base)(h)

  4. For a Trapezoidal Prism: Volume = 1/2 (altitude)(base + base'))(h))
    • For and inscribed Trapezoidal Pyramid: Volume = 1/3((1/2 (altitude)(base + base'))(h))

There is sn interesting relationship between the Volume a Cylinder, and an inscribed Double Cone and Sphere:

If the height of each figure is equal to "2r" so the the radius of the Sphere is equal to "r", the Volume of the Cylinder and Inscribed Double Cone is:

  • Volume of Cylinder = 2r3;
  • Volume of the Inscribed Double Cone = 2(1/3r3) = 2/3(r3)

The remaining 1/3 of the Volume within the Cylinder can be calculated as follows:

  • Volume = (1/3((1/2(r x 2r)2r))2 = 4/3(r3), i.e., 2r3 - 2/3r3 = 6/3r3 - 2/3r3 = 4/3r3. The formula for the Volume of a Sphere is 4/3r3.

Thus, the Volume of a Cylinder is:

  • Volume of Cylinder (2r3) = Volume of Double Cone (2/3(r3) + Volume of the Sphere (4/3(r3) = 6/3r3 = 2r3

Image Source 1
Image Source 2
Image Source 3